Map the space you actually have
Open both doors and measure the narrowest usable width, the cabinet depth and the height below the lowest pipe. Hinges, a garbage disposal and water supply valves can make a cabinet much smaller than its outside dimensions suggest. Sketch these obstacles before shopping. A full-width two-tier organizer may look efficient online but fail to slide past a drain trap.
Choose between bins, shelves and pull-outs
A removable bin suits loose bottles and is easy to lift out when you need access to plumbing. An adjustable shelf can recover space above short items. A pull-out basket helps with deep cabinets, but its rails take up width and may require screws. For a rental, confirm the installation method with your lease or landlord before drilling. Keep access to shut-off valves clear.
Buy for your everyday routine
Separate items used daily from backup supplies. Measure your tallest spray bottle, including the trigger, rather than assuming it fits. Choose a base that is easy to wipe and check whether a removable liner is included. Store household chemicals according to their labels and use appropriate child-resistant storage; an open basket is not a safety solution.
Use a modest budget first
Treat the under-$100 category as a spending ceiling, not a target. You may only need one tray and two existing containers. Try the layout for a week before adding a second tier. Save larger purchases for cabinets where accessibility is a repeated problem, rather than organizing every cupboard at once.